Informed Consent for Publication

Editorial Policies

Informed Consent for Publication

The Review of Studies on Criminology, Sociology, and Law (RSCSL) is committed to protecting the dignity, rights, privacy, and welfare of individuals who participate in research. Authors are responsible for ensuring that research involving human participants is conducted in accordance with applicable ethical principles, institutional requirements, and legal regulations. Where manuscripts include information that could identify an individual, appropriate informed consent for publication must be obtained before submission.

This policy is particularly relevant to research involving crime victims, offenders, detainees, law enforcement personnel, judicial officers, vulnerable populations, community members, and other individuals whose identities, personal information, or sensitive circumstances require special protection.

 

Scope of the Policy

This policy applies to manuscripts that contain:

  • Identifiable personal information;
  • Photographs or images of individuals;
  • Audio or video recordings;
  • Interview excerpts that may reveal identity;
  • Case reports or case studies involving identifiable persons;
  • Court documents or legal materials containing personal identifiers;
  • Sensitive qualitative data;
  • Any information that could reasonably permit the identification of an individual, directly or indirectly.

The requirement for informed consent applies regardless of whether the individual is named.

 

Protection of Participant Privacy

Authors must make every reasonable effort to protect the privacy and confidentiality of research participants.

Information that should normally be removed or anonymized includes, but is not limited to:

  • Names and initials;
  • Facial photographs or recognizable images;
  • Residential addresses;
  • Telephone numbers;
  • Email addresses;
  • Social media accounts or usernames;
  • Institutional or workplace identifiers;
  • Audio or video recordings containing identifiable information;
  • Police report numbers;
  • Court case numbers where disclosure could compromise confidentiality;
  • Medical, legal, correctional, or educational records;
  • Unique demographic information that could reasonably reveal identity.

Text, tables, figures, appendices, supplementary materials, and datasets should all be reviewed carefully to ensure participant confidentiality.

 

Requirement for Informed Consent

When identifiable information cannot be fully anonymized or when publication itself may reveal a participant's identity, authors must obtain written informed consent for publication before submitting the manuscript.

The informed consent process should ensure that participants understand:

  • The purpose of the research;
  • The purpose of publication;
  • What information will be published;
  • The potential audience for the publication;
  • That published material may remain permanently available through open-access publication and indexing services;
  • Any reasonably foreseeable risks associated with publication;
  • Their voluntary agreement to publication.
Consent should be obtained before submission whenever publication involves identifiable information.
 

Research Involving Vulnerable Populations

Additional protections are expected for research involving:

  • Children and adolescents;
  • Persons deprived of liberty;
  • Crime victims;
  • Survivors of violence or abuse;
  • Individuals with diminished decision-making capacity;
  • Indigenous Peoples and culturally distinct communities;
  • Refugees, migrants, and displaced populations;
  • Persons under judicial supervision;
  • Other vulnerable or legally protected groups.

Where participants cannot legally provide informed consent, written permission must be obtained from a parent, legal guardian, or other legally authorized representative in accordance with applicable laws and institutional ethical requirements.

Authors should also ensure that participation is voluntary and free from coercion or undue influence.

 

Ethical Approval

Research involving human participants should receive prior approval from an appropriate Institutional Review Board (IRB), Research Ethics Committee (REC), or equivalent ethics body whenever required by institutional policies or applicable regulations.

Authors should provide within the manuscript:

  • Name of the ethics committee;
  • Approval or protocol number, where applicable;
  • Date of approval, when available.

Where ethical approval was not required, authors should provide a clear explanation.

Ethical approval does not replace the requirement to obtain informed consent when consent is necessary.
 

Author Responsibilities

By submitting a manuscript, authors confirm that:

  • Appropriate informed consent was obtained where required;
  • All necessary ethical approvals were secured before conducting the research;
  • Participant confidentiality has been protected;
  • Identifiable information has been published only with appropriate permission;
  • Consent documentation will be retained securely and can be provided to the Editorial Office upon reasonable request.

The journal normally does not require submission of consent forms in order to protect participant confidentiality but may request confirmation or documentation if ethical concerns arise.

 

Editorial Assessment

During editorial evaluation, the Editorial Office may request clarification regarding:

  • Ethical approval;
  • Participant consent;
  • Anonymization procedures;
  • Protection of confidential information;
  • Compliance with institutional or national ethical requirements.

Where concerns cannot be satisfactorily resolved, editorial consideration may be suspended or the manuscript may be rejected.

 

Post-Publication Privacy Concerns

If concerns regarding participant privacy or informed consent arise after publication, RSCSL will investigate the matter in accordance with its Publication Ethics Policy.

Depending on the circumstances, the journal may:

  • Request correction or anonymization of published material;
  • Publish a correction or editorial notice;
  • Issue an Expression of Concern;
  • Retract the article;
  • Remove content where necessary to comply with legal or ethical obligations.

Editorial actions will seek to balance the integrity of the scholarly record with the protection of participants' rights and welfare.

Confidentiality of Consent Documentation

Authors are responsible for securely maintaining informed consent documentation in accordance with applicable institutional, legal, and ethical requirements.

Consent documents should not be submitted for publication unless specifically requested by the Editorial Office during an ethics investigation.

Any documentation provided to the journal will be treated confidentially.

Commitment to Ethical Research

The Review of Studies on Criminology, Sociology, and Law (RSCSL) is committed to promoting ethical research practices that respect the autonomy, dignity, privacy, and rights of research participants. By requiring appropriate informed consent, safeguarding confidential information, and supporting responsible reporting practices, the journal strengthens public trust in scholarly publishing and ensures that published research meets internationally recognized standards of research ethics and integrity.

 

Alignment with International Standards

This Informed Consent for Publication Policy has been developed in accordance with internationally recognized principles of research ethics, participant protection, and responsible scholarly publishing and is aligned with:

  • Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – Guidance on ethical oversight, informed consent, confidentiality, protection of research participants, and publication ethics:
    https://publicationethics.org/
  • International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) – Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work, particularly the recommendations relating to privacy, confidentiality, informed consent, and protection of research participants:
    https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/
  • Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) – Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, including requirements for ethical oversight, participant protection, and responsible editorial policies:
    https://doaj.org/apply/guide/

RSCSL periodically reviews and updates this policy to ensure continued alignment with evolving international standards for research ethics, publication integrity, participant protection, and responsible open-access scholarly publishing.