Women Who Lead: A Multiple Case Study Of Female School Heads Breaking Barriers And Redefining Educational Leadership

Authors

  • Evangeline D. Pagal University of the Immaculate Conception image/svg+xml Author
  • Thelma O. Alderite, EdD University of the Immaculate Conception image/svg+xml Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.68354/743926

Keywords:

College presidents, Educational leadership, Gender-related barriers, Higher education governance, Multiple-case study, Philippines, Role congruity, Women's leadership

Abstract

Introduction: Women dominate the teaching workforce but remain underrepresented in senior higher education positions. Philippine research rarely examines women leading public colleges.

Objective: This study explored how female college presidents in Davao Region (Region XI) enact leadership, experience gender-related barriers, employ strategies, and differ across cases.

Methods: A qualitative multiple-case design involved five purposively selected presidents from one local and four state colleges. Semi-structured interviews, supplementary informant interviews, field notes, and institutional documents supported triangulation. Braun and Clarke's six-phase thematic analysis examined within- and cross-case patterns. Ethical approval was granted by the University of the Immaculate Conception Research Ethics Committee (GS-ER-04-26-0638).

Results: Fifteen themes emerged. Leadership practices included integrity, participatory decisions, balanced empathy and firmness, experiential growth, and institutional improvement. Barriers involved gender stereotypes, credibility demands, tensions between care and authority, competing personal roles, and persistent gender expectations. Strategies included strengthening competence, service-oriented leadership, institutionalizing voice, delegation, and gender inclusion. Experiences varied by career path, tenure, institutional mandate, resources, and family circumstances.

Conclusions: Presidents established legitimacy through competence, ethics, and results, exercising authority through directive and distributed approaches. Findings support feminist leadership perspectives and Role Congruity Theory and highlight the need for mentoring, transparent selection, and executive support for women in public higher education.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-13

Data Availability Statement

The survey questionnaires and interview guide used in this study are included in the appendices of the manuscript. De-identified quantitative survey data may be obtained from the corresponding author, Aye Brant C. Bueno, upon reasonable request, subject to applicable ethical and data privacy requirements. Qualitative interview transcripts and audio recordings are not publicly available to protect participants’ confidentiality and anonymity.

How to Cite

Pagal, E., & Alderite, T. (2026). Women Who Lead: A Multiple Case Study Of Female School Heads Breaking Barriers And Redefining Educational Leadership. Review of Economics, Accounting, Business, and Management Studies, 1(1), 135-151. https://doi.org/10.68354/743926